In the WSJ, Robert Plomin writes,

DNA is the major systematic influence making us who we are as individuals. Environmental influences are important too, but what look like systematic effects of the environment are often genetic effects in disguise: Parents respond to their children’s genetically driven traits, and children seek, modify and even create experiences correlated with their genetic propensities.

His book is Blueprint, which I just finished. His thesis:

DNA is the only thing that makes a substantial systematic difference, accounting for 50 percent of the variance in psychological traits. The rest comes down to chance environmental experiences that do not have long-term effects.

What he calls “chance environmental experiences” could be measurement error. Measurement error always holds down correlation. This raises the possibility that some traits that are measured with error are more heritable than they appear. For example, Gregory Clark found that social status is much more heritable across many generations than would be expected based on parent-child heritability estimates. I explained that this is likely due to error in measurement in social status, which lowers immediate-generation correlation more than multi-generation correlation.

Educational interventions are apparent environmental influences that wear off over time. You raise a test score but do not fundamentally alter ability. That is an element of what I call the Null Hypothesis, which Plomin strongly endorses, although of course he does not use that term. Related: Scott Alexander on pre-school.

This is one of the most important books of the year. Coincidentally, the NYT has an article on economists’ use of polygenic scores. Tyler and Alex both linked to it.

But you should know that I came away from Plomin’s book less than impressed with polygenic scoring. So much data mining. So little predictive value. Also, there is serious criticism of his view that environmental factors exhibit no systematic influence, but he does not confront it. I did a search inside the Kindle edition for “Flynn” and found no results.